Masks are very effective in decreasing the spread of COVID-19. However, they make it more difficult to communicate by obscuring facial expressions. Lipreading becomes impossible for for deaf and hard of hearing people. It also makes it more difficult for children and older adults to communicate orally. These populations have more difficulty hearing the “other content of speech” such as emotion. For those who use American Sign Language, facial expressions are crucial to convey meaning.
Facial shields may be a way around masks. They seem to decrease the amount of inhaled flu virus. Flu is another respiratory virus like COVID-19 that has similar transmission dynamics. In addition, shields may keep hands from faces better than masks. They also protect virus from landing inside the eyes.
A new study from Drs. Bhaskar and Arun in India and published in JAMA provides the first scientific insight into whether shields work to prevent COVID-19 spread. This is a “before and after” study with community workers who were responsible for counseling the family members of COVID-19 patients. The study looked at COVID-19 infections before (no facial shields) and after (with facial shields). In both conditions, masks, physical distancing, and infection control techniques were used. The community workers were separated from the outside world. They had no interactions with anyone except for the families of COVID-19 patients.
The “before” period was 2 weeks long. Immediately following the “before” condition, the “after” study period followed. It was also 2 weeks long. Before facial shields, there were 12 COVID-19 infections in 62 workers (19%). The first worker became sick 13 days after beginning home visits. The workers had no other contacts. This suggests that the source of the infection was the COVID-19 exposed families. After using facial shields there were no infections. Note that in both before and after conditions, facial masks were used.
This suggests that facial shields decrease the rate of COIVD-19 infections when used with surgical masks. It does not provide direct evidence that they work independently of masks. However, the workers used masks all through the study period. This provides indirect evidence that facial shields may provide a high degree of protection.
Strengths of this study: This is a community setting using trained healthcare workers. This means that the workers are very well aware of the proper use of masks, shields, gloves, and sanitizer. There are specific ways that masks and shields should be put on, taken off, and cared for. Without proper use, the ability to control infection gets substantially worse. These facts about this study provides greater evidence than a news article suggesting that facial shields did not work in a restaurant and hotel.
Drawbacks of this study:
Bottom line: Masks were there first and are the “gold standard” by which to compare every other community prevention method. Shields are likely quite effective. We still don’t know how they compare to masks. So don’t ditch your mask for a shield just yet. Use a facial mask with a clear window. For homemade masks, a thin film of dish soap can prevent fogging.
For severe hearing loss, hearing aids aren't the best option. For many, a cochlear implant has a greater chance of improving hearing. Read on to hear the perspective of a cochlear implant surgeon who also has cochlear implants.Read Full article
Cochlear implants can cost over $100,000. Read more to learn how to understand insurance, minimize your costs, and start your journey to hearing better.Read Full article
Have a plan in place before you get sick. Being prepared ahead of time is key. In an epidemic, the hospital can be overwhelming. You may be in a temporary isolation tent or placed in a hallway. You may not have access to communication tools that you usually get. Again, being prepared ahead of time is key. Make a plan with your family if you’re not ready.Read Full article
In the hospital, COVID-19 creates unique challenges for those with hearing loss. COVID-19 patients are separated from other other patients into “respiratory isolation.” This means that masks and noisy air purifiers are widely used. Masks that muffle the voice and prevent lipreading. Unlike other medical settings, masks will not be lowered so that you can lipread.Read Full article
Like other technology, cochlear implants (CI) are continually improved. Dr. Ruffin has been a scientist involved in cochlear implant research for 15 years. He provides a birds-eye view of CI research in the HLAA Washington State Fall 2019 issue of Soundwaves.Read Full article